Skip to main content

Celebrities and Diet Culture

I will be honest - when I first saw Lizzo's post yesterday discussing some form of "detox" regimen she has been following, the body image advocate in me was disappointed.  But then as I sat back and thought for a moment, something occurred to me:

It's none of my fucking business.

Lizzo's post is the perfect example that celebrities are not immune to diet culture. We cannot and should not be mad or disappointed at the person being sucked into diet culture; but instead the grasp that the dieting industry has on all of us - no matter where we are on our body image journey.  

Sure, as a dietitian working in eating disorders, it makes me nervous that young followers who idolize her may follow in her footsteps. It's also not unbeknownst to me that Lizzo is someone who many in the body positive or fat positive communities look up to.  But this got me thinking - never once to my knowledge did Lizzo ASK to be a body image advocate along with her celebrity title.  This is a label that has been placed on her by the media - because God forbid, someone who identifies as a fat, black woman solely be recognized for her singing...she has to constantly explain her body size and worth in this fat-phobic and racist society, too.  

I'm torn, because I will own up that my initial reaction was disappointment, but then it made me reflect at how I've demonized other celebrities in the media for going on or promoting diets. Jennifer Lopez, for one, is someone I've angrily tagged in Instagram stories for promoting a dangerous elimination diet. The entire Kardashian/Jenner clan are others whom not only promote diet culture, but actually make money and profit off of sham diet supplements and waist trainer products. I think the latter example is a rightful place for the anti-diet movement to spend time and energy educating the mass public...but can we really be upset with celebrities being open about their dieting cycles when a majority of Americans will also do the same at some point in their lifetime?

Here's my take-away: it's okay and normal to grieve potentially losing such an outspoken and popular advocate in fat activism.  But by falling prey to cancel culture instead of attacking the system that keeps diets and weight stigma alive, then we really aren't going to get anywhere anytime soon. Diet culture isn't the shark - it's the water - and everybody is swimming in it. We have to hold compassion and grace for everyone, even if the negative side effects of diets are crystal clear for us.  Because most likely that person does not know they are causing harm....and it's only when you know better, you can then DO better.



Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

When "Food As Medicine" Isn't Always Helpful

I recently listened to a podcast (I'll share the link below) that really inspired me to write my own post on the topic. Throughout my dietetics career, I myself have spouted the term "Food is your medicine" to clients in a number of different settings.  Let's be honest - it's simple, catchy, almost tongue in cheek; hence why it's used in sooooo many taglines by professionals giving nutrition education.  I think most people who use it aren't intending harm, but rather trying to meet clients or audiences where they are at.  In our dietetics curriculum, we are taught that there are many health benefits to consuming a variety of nutrients, so at the surface level, treating what you eat as "medicine" might feel useful at first. So where could this otherwise harmless statement actually become harmful ?  In my experience working with disordered eating patients, "Food as medicine" can become a way for the ED to twist and factualize the client...
4 comments
Read more

What Health at Every Size REALLY Means

The Health at Every Size movement (also known by it's acronym, HAES) has a mission to provide compassionate health care to ALL.  Straight from it's web resource www.haescommunity.com : " Health at Every Size® principles help us advance social justice, create an inclusive and respectful community, and support people of all sizes in finding compassionate ways to take care of themselves. But first, let's start from the beginning.  In 2010, before this was considered a "movement," Dr. Linda Bacon wrote & published the book Health at Every Size , which was based on her groundbreaking research to de-stigmatize our society's view on weight and health.  If you try to order a copy of this book online, its description on Amazon says it all: "Fat isn't the problem.  Dieting is."  Contrary to popular belief, HAES is NOT about foregoing all health and nutrition information - in fact it isn't even anti-weight loss!  Let's dive ...
1 comment
Read more

Patience is a Virtue

I am a firm believer that everything happens for a reason.  I'm also convinced that God places events and people in our lives at exactly the right moments when we need them - making the "when it happened" just as significant as the "what happened." Although the above statements are straight from me, over the past few months my belief in them has been tested.  There have been times I've questioned my true calling, my passions, my "roles" I'm supposed to be in this world...you get the picture.  Things I'd been looking forward to weren't happening as I had hoped, and I was becoming overly anxious and stressed. During this time of questioning I completed a 9-week course through my church called 'CORE' and was surprised by the outcome.  I learned so much about myself, my faith...It even dawned on me that I may not hold the control switch to my life as much as I would like to think I do.  Newsflash to Abbie:  God has his own pl...
2 comments
Read more